At long last, the New York Times heard about the handshaking lemma. I feel avenged for the countless times I tried to explain this to people.
Monday, August 13, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Informatics Weekly, written by Mihai Pătraşcu.
![[home]](http://people.csail.mit.edu/mip/images/home.gif){kind=small}
Blog Archive
-
▼
2007
(51)
-
▼
August
(17)
- Led Zeppelin
- Love thy predecessor (II): The comparison model
- Love thy predecessor (I): In the beginning was the...
- Alan Turing and the nature of the beast
- Cute Problem (I)
- Informatics Olympiads: The End
- Informatics Olympiads (IV): Besides the IOI
- Informatics Olympiads (III): Understanding Results
- Informatics Olympiads (II): Why Should I Care?
- Informatics Olympiads (I): The Contest
- Math in the news
- Binary Search Trees (IV): Splay Trees
- Binary Search Trees (III): Online
- Binary Search Trees (II): Lower Bounds
- SODA
- Binary Search Trees (I)
- China
-
▼
August
(17)
Recent Comments
Some Theory Blogs
- Lipton (Gödel’s Letter)
- Trevisan (in theory)
- Mitzenmacher (My Biased Coin)
- Andrew (Polylogblog)
- Suresh V. (The Geomblog)
- Fortnow/Gasarch (Complexity)
- S. Aaronson (Shtetl-Optimized)
- Muthu (My Slice of Pizza)
- James Lee (TCS Math)
- Erickson (3D Pancakes)
- Noam Nisan (AGT)
- Gudmundsson (Dense Outliers)
- D. Eppstein (0xDE)
4 comments:
Note the subtle difference between mean and median...
In more detail:
http://justoneminute.typepad.com/main/2007/08/they-cant-mean-.html
- grad student, addled from grading, whose non-mathy friends pointed this out to him
Gale & Graham's comments are correct but they don't contradict the claims of the study. There's a big difference between median and average. (I do think people are lying though.)
Sure, it's always easy to play the purist-formalist and jump at the neck of the NY Times editors. But in our imperfect world, seldom does a non-constructive purist or formalist opinion move things forward...
What should we choose -- science articles which are not formally conclusive but at least make people think, or let people form an stupid opinion and feeling good about it?
BTW, since we're wondering about tails, here's another excerpt from the study's conclusion: 29 percent of American men report having 15 or more female sexual partners in a lifetime, while only 9 percent of women report having sex with 15 or more men.
The british study, in which men reported an average of 12.7 partners, and women 6.5, presumably -was- dealing in means, not medians, and so the article makes a valid point, although perhaps should not have mentioned the median statistic from the american study.
Post a Comment